Unlock Requirements for "Bad Luck, I Guess"

"Bad Luck, I Guess" unlocks when Lucia, without Jason, robs the same Little Cuba Payday Loans from the Prologue again after the Chapter 3 main mission Credit Check (Meet Raul’s Crew), then escapes on foot.

Gamer Guides lists the trophy description ("Second time's the charm."); PowerPyx details the conditions and steps.

PlatformPS5
Trophy"Bad Luck, I Guess" — "Second time's the charm."
Earliest AvailabilityAfter Chapter 3 main mission Credit Check (Meet Raul’s Crew)
Prerequisite UnlocksPayday Loans robberies and the Dye Pack Jammer
Store LocationPayday Loans in Vice City, Little Cuba (same store Lucia robbed in the Prologue)
Character ConditionLucia alone, without Jason
Escape MethodOn foot only (driving away in a vehicle does not unlock it)

GTA VI PS5 trophy list and Platinum requirements

How to Rob the Little Cuba Payday Loans and Escape

PowerPyx outlines the following sequence for completing the robbery and triggering the trophy once Payday Loans robberies are unlocked in Chapter 3.

Watch Lucia unlock Bad Luck, I Guess (PowerPyx)
  1. Complete the Chapter 3 main mission Credit Check (Meet Raul’s Crew) to unlock Payday Loans robberies.
  2. Go alone as Lucia, without Jason, to the Payday Loans store in Little Cuba, Vice City, which is the same store she robbed during the Prologue.
  3. Enter the store and aim your weapon at the teller, causing security to open fire on you.
  4. Defeat security.
  5. Break through the door.
  6. Take all the money from the 3 cash drawers.
  7. Leave on foot, escape the police search area, and keep running until the delayed unlock triggers.

Watch the Little Cuba walkthrough as Lucia (PowerPyx)

Why "Bad Luck, I Guess" Didn't Unlock

If the trophy didn't unlock, check that (1) Jason was not with Lucia, (2) you did not drive away in a vehicle, and (3) you kept running far enough on foot after leaving the police search area (PowerPyx). The unlock is delayed and does not trigger immediately.

PowerPyx's steps do not say whether you need to use the Dye Pack Jammer, and the guide does not specify an exact distance you must run before the trophy unlocks.