Outcome Comparison: Telling Lucia vs Letting the Timer Run Out
Spoiler warning: this guide covers story events in Chapter 1, Swamped and Recalibration.
Telling Lucia gives an immediate relationship boost and also lets you avoid the argument and relationship drop at the end of Recalibration, while letting the timer run out gives no boost and leads to a big argument at the end of Recalibration followed by a relationship drop.
Whether you mention Brian's retirement changes the immediate relationship boost and whether an argument breaks out at the end of Recalibration.
This comparison cross-checks PowerPyx, Game8, and The Games Wiki; the platform, build, and region they used are unspecified.
| Tell Lucia (press the button) | Raises your relationship level with Lucia on the spot. Later in Recalibration, Cal brings up Brian's retirement and Lucia supports Jason on the drive back. You also avoid the end-of-mission argument and relationship drop. |
|---|---|
| Let the timer run out (stay silent) | Skips the immediate relationship boost. Later, Jason and Lucia have a big argument at the end of Recalibration, and your relationship level drops afterward. |
How relationship levels with Lucia rise and fall
See the Swamped: Mention Brian's Retirement rows in The Games Wiki's choices table
When the MENTION BRIAN'S RETIREMENT Prompt Appears and How to Choose
After Brian announces his retirement near the end of Chapter 1, Swamped, the story jumps ahead by about one week to Jason's home in Key Lento.
In a still that Clutchbase took from GameRiot's PS5 Pro footage (English UI), a single MENTION BRIAN'S RETIREMENT prompt with a Cross icon appears in the top-right corner while Jason is in the shower.
Beebom's English walkthrough lists Cross on PlayStation and A on Xbox; the gameplay image only confirms the Cross prompt. If the timer runs out, you get the not-telling outcome.
- Play through Chapter 1, Swamped, until the cutscene where Brian announces his retirement.
- In the shower scene at Jason's home in Key Lento, look for the "One Week Later" title card, then wait for the choice prompt to appear.
- When MENTION BRIAN'S RETIREMENT appears in the top-right corner, press Cross on PlayStation or A on Xbox (A per Beebom's walkthrough) before the timer expires to speak up, or wait without pressing anything to stay silent.
Unconfirmed Details: Timer Length, Retrying the Choice, Japanese UI Text, and Ending Impact
The exact number of seconds on the choice timer and the Japanese UI wording for the prompt remain unconfirmed. Whether you can redo the choice after the timer expires is also unconfirmed.
Whether this single choice directly affects the game's ending is also unconfirmed.
A Japanese X post from @Nick247X mentions a possible impact on the final ending in its opening text and at the bottom of an attached side-by-side diagram comparing improved and worsened relationships, but it includes no gameplay screenshots comparing endings.
Likewise, the branching sections on Game8 and The Games Wiki do not list any condition linking this choice alone to a specific ending.
See @Nick247X's explainer graphic on X (a diagram, not gameplay footage)
How to Start Recalibration, Where the Outcome Plays Out
The start conditions for Recalibration, the mission where the outcome of telling or not telling Lucia plays out, are covered in the guide below.