Are Occupied Cars Stealable From the Start?

In a pre-launch IGN demonstration and interview reprinted by Best Buy Gamers, Rockstar North's Rob Nelson explained that you have the option to carjack a car with a driver from the start: while progression and tools are required for certain parked vehicles, he stated that you can always carjack any driver you see.

All Things How and Notebookcheck similarly cover this driver-occupied scenario in their pre-launch reporting.

In post-launch coverage, GTABase's Andy also explains that occupied vehicles on the road can still be taken the classic way by pulling the driver out and driving off.

Rob Nelson on carjacking from the start

Reported Controls for Carjacking a Running Vehicle

For the starting inputs, RetroBroker is the sole source reporting Triangle on PS5 and Y on Xbox Series X|S for an engine-running car with a driver in Story Mode.

While RetroBroker's table also lists start-of-game availability, that remains its own claim rather than a verified retail chapter check, and neither the applicable regional version nor the identity of any gameplay tester is confirmed.

Separately, the resistance button-mash struggle is reported by PC Gamer—whose account does not specify the platform, build, chapter, or regional version—and although RetroBroker's prose also mentions rapid tapping, independent gameplay verification remains unconfirmed and the two reports do not show a single tested sequence.

The approach prompt, mash button, exact chapter, tool requirements, passenger reactions, and applicable regional version remain unconfirmed.

  1. PS5: Triangle (RetroBroker’s sole report for a car with a driver and its engine running in Story Mode; retail gameplay verification unconfirmed)
  2. Xbox Series X|S: Y (RetroBroker’s sole report for a car with a driver and its engine running in Story Mode; retail gameplay verification unconfirmed)

RetroBroker's reported starting inputs for PS5 and Xbox Series X|S

What Happens When a Driver Resists

In PC Gamer, Christopher Livingston reports that a resisting driver can lead to a button-mash struggle.

RetroBroker's retail table also notes possible retaliation or gunfire by the driver when carjacking a running vehicle.

The table below lists outcomes described by different publications, keeping GTABase's account separate from PC Gamer's account of resistance and loss.

PC Gamer's Christopher Livingston reports that driver resistance triggers a rapid button-mashing struggle, leading to distinct outcomes depending on how the encounter plays out.

After removing a driver from a car on the road (GTABase's account)Reportedly lets you pull the driver out and drive off (described by GTABase's Andy as a general road carjacking, not confirmed as the outcome of winning a button-mash struggle)
After the driver is pulled outPC Gamer reports that the driver may still open fire
Losing the button-mash struggleThe driver slams your head against the side of the car, knocks you down, and speeds away (reported only by PC Gamer)

PC Gamer's report on driver resistance and what happens if you lose

What Remains Unconfirmed About Carjacking

The public materials reviewed did not show the full retail sequence from the approach prompt through starting input, rapid-tap prompt, and outcome on PS5 or Xbox Series X|S.

Visual notes: In the candidate URL (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W47z7uL-em8, EKW the gamer), the observed public storyboard interval at 2:39–2:56 only displays sequential text over a background image—CARJACKING, an explanation that no tools are needed when stopped, and descriptions of resistance, rapid tapping, and failure attributed to PC Gamer.

Because this preview contains no footage showing the in-game button prompts and controls through the outcome, it was rejected as verification.

Exact mash buttonPC Gamer’s excerpt describes rapid tapping. The exact button remains unconfirmed.
Chapter and tool conditionsThe exact chapter when this becomes available and whether any tool is required remain unverified in the PS5 and Xbox Series X|S retail versions.
Passenger behaviorUnverified whether passengers resist or change behavior compared with a solo driver