When and where can you start fishing?

You can start fishing at the Key Lento pier once Jason first gains free roam. This comes from Bill Lavoy's launch guide on Shacknews.

See Jason fishing from the dock in the gameplay image (Shacknews)

How to cast, hook, and reel in (PlayStation button notation)

The steps use the PlayStation button labels in the Shacknews and GTA BOOM launch guides. The right-stick rotation steps assume the default Rotate setting documented by ViceManual.

Jason fishes from the jetty with the Control and Reel In prompts on screen.
Open full-size image · Screenshot: GTA BOOM · CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 · Game imagery © Rockstar Games
  1. At the water, hold L1 to open the Weapons wheel. Select the Equipment tab with the right stick, then use L2 or R2 to select Fishing Rod.
  2. Keep holding L2 to grip the rod. Hold R2 to pull the rod back, then release R2 to cast.
  3. Once the lure lands, keep holding L2 and slowly rotate the right stick to attract a fish.
  4. When a fish bites, press R2 to hook it.
  5. Move the left stick opposite the direction the fish is swimming. Tilt the right stick in any direction to limit how much line the fish pulls out, then ease off the right stick before the line breaks.
  6. When the fish stops moving, rotate the right stick to reel it in with the default Rotate setting.

Troubleshooting and the in-game help

If you can't start fishing, check two things: that Jason has reached his first free-roam section, and that you are at the water.

The in-game Fishing Tips page covers the types of water you can fish in and how to stop a hooked fish from pulling out more line. ViceManual verified that help on PS5 at launch.

You can check the default Rotate method in the settings menu.

If the rod is missing from the Equipment tab in the Weapons wheel, GTA BOOM’s hands-on guide shows another option at Key Lento. Press L1 at the rod stand beside the white boat on the pier to pick up the rod.

ViceManual's test setupPS5, launch version, English UI
In-game help path (English UI)Help → Exploration → Fishing Tips
Waters mentioned in the helpRivers, lakes, and the ocean
Limit line payout after hooking a fish (in-game help)Tilt the right stick in any direction, then ease off before the line breaks
Fishing controls and default setting (English UI)Settings → Gameplay → Fishing. The default is Rotate

Can you keep or sell fish caught in free roam?

GTA BOOM’s hands-on launch guide shows that you can release fish from the catch screen at the Key Lento pier. The sources consulted do not confirm that you can keep or sell fish caught in free roam.

Rob Nelson’s pre-launch explanation, recorded by TGG, and the GTA Base Fishing page also describe catch-and-release.

The story mission Recalibration has a different objective. VGC’s walkthrough records taking fish caught with Cal back to the dock to cook them during the mission.